Donna FletcherDonna FletcherDonna FletcherDonna Fletcher

Your Opinion Needed On A Book Cover!

Book covers can help sell a book or kill a book. A good book cover can catch the eye and have the person reading the description and if that hooks you, you sample a few pages and you’re hooked, or not. But most times it starts with a book cover, unless of course it’s a favorite author and she or he is an automatic buy no matter what the cover looks like. A while back I asked about an older book cover that I thought might need updating… The Highlander’s Stolen Heart. It seemed that headless, bare-chested men covers were losing favor with romance readers. Many of you liked the cover and didn’t think it needed updating, but I got to thinking. You didn’t have anything to compare it to. So, I had a new cover done for it. Now I require your opinion again. Please leave a comment as to which one you like best! Your feedback is appreciated!

Original cover

New Cover

DonnaFletcher TheHighlandersStolenHeart3 200
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
72 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ina Gibson
Ina Gibson
5 months ago

I like the Orginal best

Terri
Terri
5 months ago

I like the original one, nice abs.

DivaKylie
DivaKylie
5 months ago

Oooh… i was a dont change it vote… but i thonkwe do need the update…. it looks more sinister…. i vote that should be the dragons cover. Hahaha

Amy
Amy
5 months ago

I LOVE the new cover!!

Carrot
Carrot
5 months ago

I love highland stolen hearts ❤️ book cover by far

Evelyn
Evelyn
5 months ago

Both covers are interesting, however I like the new cover because it has action.

Maritza
Maritza
5 months ago

I still enjoy the original cover the best, it’s sexier

Joanna
Joanna
5 months ago

I love the new cover

Maria Dariotis
Maria Dariotis
5 months ago

Hey Donna, I have to say that I like both. If I had to pick tho I like the first one with the second one’s background. 😊

Tanvi Karvat
Tanvi Karvat
5 months ago

Definitely the new one !

Kris
Kris
5 months ago

My vote is for the Original cover!

PattyO
PattyO
5 months ago

Definitely the New Cover💞

Carolyn7777
Carolyn7777
5 months ago

I like the new cover better. I like seeing the heroes face. It gives me a better idea what he looks like.

Sandypo
Sandypo
5 months ago

Original cover, by a mile!

Sharon
Sharon
5 months ago

I like the first one but the new is dream worthy.

CJ-TN
CJ-TN
5 months ago

Well, I’m a designer… so I like different elements of each. LOL I like the art for the new cover, but far prefer the styling of the title on the original — it really POPS. If I have to pick one, it’d have to be the original.

Danielle
Danielle
5 months ago

The new one isn’t bad, but I much prefer the original one.

Alex
Alex
5 months ago

Love the orginal for sure.

Betty
Betty
5 months ago

Original

Martha
Martha
5 months ago

I prefer the original cover. The man in new cover looks more angry than sexy.

Unic
Unic
5 months ago
Reply to  Martha

Agreed

Mila
Mila
5 months ago

I like the new one more

Tama
Tama
5 months ago

I prefer the original cover.

Sigrid
Sigrid
5 months ago

The original

Rlhcat
Rlhcat
5 months ago

I prefer the New Cover

Amy
Amy
5 months ago

Oh my they both get my blood pumping lolll.

Roz
Roz
5 months ago

I like the original cover. It gives you a glimpse of the hero but then when you read the book it fills in the blanks and gives you the details about him. And that is what I feel about your characters in your books, we are not meant to judge them until we know them. N.B. I did have an issue with “in the arms of the highland warrior” but I guess that was how I perceived the picture.

Maddie
Maddie
5 months ago

I love the second cover. It looks much better.

Donna
Donna
5 months ago

I like the new cover better. I like to get a visual of my hero and heroine. Then get upset if the picture doesn’t match the description in the book. Lol 😆

Julie
Julie
5 months ago

I love both covers, but that new one I so much more intriguing! I say go with the update!

Susan W.
Susan W.
5 months ago

Keep the first, imagination can fill in the rest. That said, the new one is very nice, how about later?

Nancy
Nancy
5 months ago

Tough choice but if I am being honest, I like the original cover.

Ray
Ray
5 months ago

I like both covers. However, the new cover is very eye catching and lends to the visual fantasy of the hero of the book.
I would have liked to see the heroine in the background as if the hero is protecting her.
My vote goes to the new cover.

Valorie Scott
Valorie Scott
5 months ago

I have an opinion on both. The new cover is wonderful, IF the Highlander didn’t look so much like Fabio with dark hair! Lol!
The original cover is sexy and it allows us to imagine what this man might look like as we form an image in our mind as we read the book! Lol!
My vote would be to change up the face of the man on the new cover and then go with that cover!
Whatever it turns out to be, I’ll love it regardless!❤️

Grams
Grams
5 months ago

The original!

Beth
Beth
5 months ago

I prefer the original cover

Annette
Annette
5 months ago

I would have to say I like them both. However my grip with changing covers is this.I end up buying the same book that has had the cover changed out. Then I get the new one and a chapter in it’s oh good grief. I’ve already read this book or own it.

Alaina
Alaina
5 months ago

I love the original cover the best. Don’t change it!

Tina
Tina
5 months ago

I like the original one better.

Mary k
Mary k
5 months ago

I agree, the new cover is great

Glittergirl
Glittergirl
5 months ago

I prefer the original cover. I like the yellow title and the manly chest. The new one looks like a recycled older cover of another author I follow.

Jody
Jody
5 months ago

I love the original! Don’t change it!

Sherry
Sherry
5 months ago

Both are strong covers and have good points. I like the color scheme, font, and layout of the title in the original; that yellow really pops against the red. I also like the castle in the background. I think I prefer the new one though as I like seeing the hero’s face.

Windygail
Windygail
5 months ago

I prefer the original one.

Shell
Shell
5 months ago

The original. No face. Sometimes the face on the cover doesn’t match the face that the writer creates in my mind.

Sabrina Gibson
Sabrina Gibson
5 months ago

I like the original one best.

Wendy
Wendy
5 months ago

I prefer the original!

Dee
Dee
5 months ago

Definitely the new one! Hot Scot!

Vbi104
Vbi104
5 months ago

The original, I like the chest.

Carrol
Carrol
5 months ago

I prefer the original cover

Jan
Jan
5 months ago

I like the original cover. Sometimes the model’s looks don’t match the description I the book.

Where to Buy Donna's Books

  • Buy on AppleBooks
  • Buy on Amazon
  • Buy on Barnes & Noble
  • Buy from Google Play
  • Buy from Kobo
  • Buy from Audible

Donna’s books are also available at Books-A-Million.

Join Newsletter

Subscribe to my newsletter to find out about my latest books and news:

You have Successfully Subscribed!